Long Island Diners
Long Island is arguably the "Diner Capital" of the world. Whether you’re looking for a 2 a.m. burger, a high-end "gastro-diner" experience, or a nostalgic 1950s booth, Long Island has a diner for you.
Here are some of the best and most iconic diners across Nassau and Suffolk counties:
The Iconic Classics
These are the heavy hitters that have been around for decades and are often voted "Best of Long Island."
Thomas’ Ham & Eggery (Carle Place): A local legend since 1946. It’s small, perpetually crowded, and famous for serving breakfast in individual skillet pans.
Try: Any of the egg skillets or their signature corned beef hash.
Landmark Diner (Roslyn): A massive, two-story institution that recently underwent a modern revamp. It manages to feel upscale while keeping the classic "everything-on-the-menu" diner spirit.
Try: Their specialty pancakes or Greek platters.
Northport Shipwreck Diner (Northport): Housed in a vintage 1920s railroad car, this spot is pure nostalgia. It’s right near the harbor and perfect for a cozy morning.
Try: Homemade blintzes or classic French toast.
Best for Families & Decorations
Some diners go all-out on atmosphere, making them a hit for kids and holiday lovers.
Oconee East Diner (Islip): Known for its over-the-top holiday decor (they decorate for every major holiday) and the "freebies"—they often hand out lollipops or cookies to kids.
Munday’s (Huntington): Located in the heart of Huntington Village, this feels more like an old-school soda fountain/luncheonette. It’s bright, cheerful, and perfect for a post-shopping lunch.
Lindenhurst Diner (Lindenhurst): A modern favorite that has won "Best Diner" multiple times recently. They’ve leaned into the "Instagrammable" trend with massive, over-the-top milkshakes served in mason jars.
The "Gastro-Diner" & Modern Favorites
If you want diner portions but "chef-crafted" quality, these spots have updated the classic menu.
The Pantry (Rockville Centre): Often described as a gastro-diner, it features a cleaner, more modern interior and a menu that includes things like avocado toast and high-end burgers alongside classic eggs.
Dix Hills Diner (Huntington): Known for being a bit "fancier" than your average spot. The portions are enormous, and the interior is sleek and very clean.
Premier Diner (Commack): A local powerhouse that stays busy thanks to its consistent quality and famous pastrami and eggs.
Signature Dishes to Look For
If you’re visiting these specific spots, keep an eye out for these famous items:
Laurel Diner (Long Beach): Mug Full O' Pie - A literal beer mug stuffed with hot fruit pie, ice cream, and whipped cream.
International Delight Cafe (Bellmore): "The World" - Not a traditional diner, but their dessert menu is legendary, featuring 30+ scoops of gelato.
Lindenhurst Diner (Linderhurst): Cheesecake Pancakes - Decadent, thick pancakes topped with actual chunks of cheesecake.
Maureen’s Kitchen (Smithtown): Baked Oatmeal - Strictly a breakfast/brunch spot (cow-themed!), but their oatmeal and stuffed French toast are legendary.
Quick Tip: Many of the most popular spots (like Thomas' or Maureen's Kitchen) are cash only or have very small parking lots. It’s always a good idea to check their payment policy before you go!
